A heartbreaking tragedy has shaken the peaceful community of Middleton, Wisconsin, following a devastating incident that claimed three lives on Tuesday, July 8, 2025. In what authorities have confirmed as a double homicide and subsequent suicide, David Pabst and Teri Pabst were senselessly taken from this world, leaving friends, neighbors, and loved ones in deep mourning and disbelief.
According to early reports from the Middleton Police Department, officers responded to a welfare check request at a quiet residential home in the early afternoon hours. What they discovered was a scene that has left the town reeling: the bodies of David Pabst, 62, and his wife, Teri Pabst, 60, both pronounced dead at the scene. The third individual, identified as a close family member who authorities believe was responsible for the killings, died from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound. Authorities have not yet released that individual’s name as the investigation continues and next of kin are notified.
David and Teri Pabst were longtime Middleton residents, known for their warmth, generosity, and deep involvement in the community. David, a retired engineer and lifelong Wisconsinite, was widely respected for his intelligence, calm demeanor, and willingness to lend a helping hand. Those who knew him describe a quiet strength and a deep love for his family. In retirement, David had found joy in gardening, fishing on Lake Mendota, and volunteering his time with local high school robotics programs, mentoring young minds and encouraging their pursuit of science and engineering.
Teri, a former elementary school teacher, was equally admired for her kindness, patience, and boundless compassion. For over two decades, she touched the lives of countless children through her work in the Middleton-Cross Plains School District. Even after her retirement, she remained active in local literacy programs and often spent her afternoons reading to children at the public library. Her smile was infectious, and her ability to make others feel seen and valued left a lasting impact on everyone she met.
The couple, married for over 35 years, were known to be inseparable. Friends recall their shared love for travel, local arts events, and the quiet joy they found in everyday life. Their relationship served as a beacon of love and partnership within their circle.
The tragedy has stunned not just their family and close friends, but the entire Middleton area. “David and Teri were the kind of people you hoped to have as neighbors,” said a tearful local resident. “They were the heart of this street. This is unimaginable.”
Police have assured the community that there is no ongoing threat and that the scene was contained to the residence. They are continuing to investigate the circumstances that led to this horrific act, including examining possible mental health or domestic stress factors. While many questions remain unanswered, what is clear is the deep and lasting wound left by the sudden loss of two beloved members of the community.
Local officials, clergy, and mental health professionals have rallied to provide support for those affected. Grief counseling services have been made available at nearby churches and community centers, and a candlelight vigil is being planned in downtown Middleton for Friday evening, where friends and residents will gather to remember the lives of David and Teri and to stand together in collective mourning and resilience.
In this moment of unimaginable sorrow, the Middleton community is being reminded of the importance of compassion, connection, and seeking help in times of emotional crisis. A statement from the Pabst family reads in part: “We are devastated beyond words. David and Teri were the anchors of our family, and their loss has left a void that can never be filled. We ask for privacy as we begin to grieve and try to make sense of this tragedy.”
The story of David and Teri Pabst is not just one of loss, but of lives well-lived—lives devoted to each other, to their community, and to making the world a better place in quiet, meaningful ways. While their physical presence is no longer with us, their legacy of kindness, generosity, and love will live on in the hearts of all who knew them.
May David and Teri Pabst rest in eternal peace. And may their memory be a source of strength and inspiration as the community of Middleton begins the long journey toward healing.